Domestic Investors vs FPIs: Why Special Tax Breaks?
India's domestic investors are playing an increasingly important role in supporting the country's capital markets through mutual funds, SIPs and institutional investments. CA Aditya Sesh examines whether foreign portfolio investors should receive special tax concessions and why India needs a fair, long-term investment and taxation policy.
Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) is welcome in India. However, foreign capital should come to the country on the strength of its economic prospects and market fundamentals, not merely because of tax exemptions or preferential treatment. When corporate earnings improve, market valuations become reasonable and growth opportunities expand, foreign investors will naturally be drawn to India.
According to data published by the Reserve Bank of India and SEBI, foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) made net equity sales of approximately ₹1.81 lakh crore in the domestic equity market during FY26, while domestic institutional investors (DIIs) made record net investments of approximately ₹8.5 lakh crore during the same period. In October 2026, foreign investors sold equities worth approximately ₹34,843 crore (US$3.6 billion) on a net basis. While FPIs turned net buyers during the second half of the month, their overall position for October remained negative.
The reported inflow of approximately $1.2 (Rs.11,400 Crores) billion in the closing days of October also indicates that foreign capital can return when market conditions are favourable. This raises an important question: should India reconsider its tax policies every time foreign investors turn net sellers?
Domestic Investors Have Emerged as a Strong Pillar of the Indian Market
Over the past five years, the Indian capital market has undergone a significant transformation. Between FY22 and FY26, Indian mutual funds made net investments of approximately ₹16 lakh crore in the secondary equity market. Individual investors, meanwhile, invested around ₹5.09 lakh crore across the primary and secondary markets.
The Strength of SIPs Cannot Be Overlooked
According to AMFI's October 2026 data, monthly investments through Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) stood at approximately ₹32,160 crore, Equity mutual funds attracted net inflows of around ₹32,994 crore during the same month, taking the mutual fund industry's total Assets Under Management (AUM) to approximately ₹83.39 lakh crore.Thus the inflows of SIP or the net Equity mutual funds equal to the monthly net inflow of the FPI’s, not a mean scale.
These numbers highlight how household savings have become a significant source of strength for India's capital markets and that the Indian capital markets are not solely dependent on foreign investors,today. When domestic investors continue to commit substantial amounts of money to the market, providing a stable source of liquidity and investment support to the market, while creating no foreign exchange volatility. Thus it is worth asking whether offering special tax concessions to foreign investors, potentially at the expense of domestic investors, is justified?
LTCG and STT Concessions: Is This the Right Approach?
There has been discussion around reducing the Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG) tax and Securities Transaction Tax (STT) to attract foreign investment. Reports emerging in November 2026 suggest that SEBI has recommended eliminating LTCG tax on foreign portfolio investors' equity investments. However, this remains a recommendation and not a final government decision.
South Korea is often cited in support of such measures, as certain categories of foreign investors there enjoy preferential capital gains tax treatment. However, India's economic circumstances and investment landscape are different. The country's domestic savings and investment base has strengthened considerably over the years.
The prevailing LTCG tax rate on eligible listed equity investments in India is 12.5% on gains exceeding the prescribed exemption threshold of ₹1.25 lakh, subject to applicable conditions. Offering foreign investors a special exemption could create an uneven playing field between domestic and foreign participants in the same market.
How Much Tax Concession Is Justified to Attract Foreign Capital?
One argument in favour of extending tax concessions to FPIs is that higher foreign capital inflows could support the rupee. A stronger rupee can help lower the cost of imports, particularly crude oil, natural gas and other essential commodities. However, currency appreciation can also reduce the rupee value of dollar-denominated export earnings, affecting exporters.
An illustrative calculation further highlights the potential tax implications. If the Indian Rupee appreciates by 1% and if an FPI investment of ₹3 lakh crore generates an annual compounded return of 10% compounded over five years, its value would grow to approximately ₹4.83 lakh crore, generating capital gains of around ₹1.83 lakh crore. At a 12.5% LTCG rate, the theoretical LTCG tax liability would be approximately ₹22,894 crore. If this is to be given up to attract FPI’s, the net surplus of this on reduction in the import bill minus the reduction in export realisation, will be absorbed in 2 financial years assuming that the Rupee appreciation will hold on to its rate for 2 years. Beyond the 2 years, sunset clauses for the benefits will have to be introduced, since continuing it will be a loss making proposition at the country level, unless Rupee keeps appreciating! This is a simplified, scenario-based calculation and not a projection of actual government tax collections or revenue losses. It does, however, underline why the potential fiscal implications of tax concessions need to be carefully examined before any policy decision is taken.
The government must consequently evaluate the broader economic impact of attracting foreign capital through tax concessions rather than assuming that higher FPI inflows or a stronger rupee will automatically translate into an overall economic gain.
Corporate Double Taxation Also Deserves Attention
While the government considers tax concessions for foreign investors, it should also examine the issue of double taxation of corporate earnings.
A company first pays tax on its profits. When a portion of those post-tax profits is distributed to shareholders as dividends, the recipients are taxed on that income as well.
India should consider a framework that appropriately recognises the tax already paid by a company at the shareholder level. The erstwhile Section 80 M of the Indian Income Tax, that deals with treatment of inter corporate dividends, could be expanded to include dividends in the hands of non corporate shareholder recipients. Further, Australia's dividend imputation system offers an example of how such an arrangement can work, allowing eligible shareholders to receive recognition for tax already paid by the company through franking credits.
A reform in this direction could benefit both domestic and foreign investors without creating preferential treatment for either. It could also improve post-tax returns for investors and encourage greater consumption, savings and reinvestment in the economy.
The Need to Look Beyond Short-Term Market Movements
India's economic strength cannot be built on foreign portfolio investment alone. The country needs policies that strengthen domestic savings, private investment, manufacturing, employment and exports.
Foreign investment should certainly be encouraged, but not through policies that create unequal treatment between domestic and overseas investors. Tax policy should be guided by long-term economic priorities rather than the immediate requirements of foreign investors or short-term fluctuations in the stock market.
India must build an economy where foreign capital flows in because of the country's growth potential, strong fundamentals and investment opportunities, not simply because of tax incentives.
By CA. Aditya Sesh, Founder and MD, Basiz Fund Services



